Thoughts on the Apple iPod announcements, where’s my $200 iPhone rebate check?

By Kevin C. Tofel | Wednesday, September 5, 2007 | 12:43 PM CT | 18 comments |

I’ve been following through the great live-blogging over at Engadget. Some interesting news which I’ll summarize in case you missed it and provide a thought or two in italics.

  • Ringtones: Available for the iPhone direct through iTunes. $0.99 for a 30-second song selection. I’m less than thrilled here as you have to pay for the song first and then pay again for the ringtone. That’s lame in my book. You’re paying for the simplicity of the solution of course, but you’re also paying for the same content twice.
  • iPod Shuffle: New colors. Nothing new here unless I missed it.
  • iPod Nano: Shorter and with a QVGA screen for CoverFlow, video and game playback. Battery life: 24 hours of audio, five for video. 4 GB = $149, 8 GB = $199. It might get tiring to watch vids on this small screen; the pixel density appears very high but I have to see the screen dimensions to be sure. Kudos to Apple for stellar battery life and for reasonable 8 GB price over the 4 GB. I predict 8 GB units to outsell the 4 GB by a factor of 3 to 1.
  • iPod Classic: Thinner and more storage. 80 GB = $249, 160 GB = $349. Unless you want to carry dozens of movies, 160 GB seems like overkill to me. Still, great battery life at 40 hours of audio and seven hours of video.
  • iPod Touch: The iPhone without the phone. 8GB = $299, 16 GB = $399. WiFi and all other iPhone features minus the phone. Until I heard the final announcement of the show, I thought these prices would kill iPhone sales. Remember the $599 justification for the iPhone was it’s an iPod and a phone. If the iPod features are $299, is the phone part worth $300? No and you’ll see in a minute that Apple agrees.
  • WiFi iTunes store: Purchase tracks directly on your iPod Touch or iPhone via WiFi. What took so long? When will the Zune have this? This could be a nail on the coffin of other online music retailers.
  • Starbucks music: Walk in to a Starbucks with your iPod Touch or iPhone and you can buy the track that’s playing in the store over free WiFi. I don’t see a huge consumer benefit here; I would have rather heard about free WiFi in all Starbucks for these devices to browse with.
  • iPhone price cut: 8 GB iPhone now $399. I’m all for risking more dollars as an early adopter, but this is a huge price cut. I’m running out to the mailbox now to see if my $200 iPhone rebate check is there. I suspect there will be many ticked off early adopters. $50…that I could swallow. 33% of what was paid recently? Not a great way to treat a customer.

Comments (18)

  • What about the 4GB? Did that drop to $299? Or drop all together? Also, what about the people who bought a 4gb for $499?

    Michael Venini6:48 AM on September 5, 2007 Reply

  • Mike, there was no mention of the 4GB iPhone, so I suspect it goes away. In fact, I just hit the Apple iPhone page tech specs and it shows 8 GB capacity only.

    Kevin C. Tofel6:51 AM on September 5, 2007 Reply

  • I was liking the iPod Classic updates, but I figured with that “name change” there was a new iPod (well HOPING) and all I have to say is that I AM IN LUST with the iPod Touch. I will be looking for the news on them shipping! I was hoping they were shipping already and would be in stores this weekend like the previous annoucements.

    As for the Starbucks, I don’t frequent them (can’t stand coffee, even smell bothers me sometimes), but I have hung out in smiliar places for food (panera bread, atlanta bread company, etc) and never have I thought it would be cool to buy that song I just heard. I wonder if the “free access” in Starbucks is JUST to the WiFiStore or full WiFi.

    Mike Hamilton7:08 AM on September 5, 2007 Reply

  • as for the price reduction. I do agree that is a big hit so close to the first release. I know that in the future the iPod touch I am going to buy will be reduced when the next gen comes down the line, but that won’t (I HOPE) be in just a couple months.

    I would seriously consider at least emailing Apple about that huge decrease and possible rebate, maybe even just a partial one. How long have you had it? with in 30 days? I would say it doesn’t hurt to try. worst they can do is say no, it’s not like they will charge you more for asking. well maybe his Jobness could get away with that :) LOL

    Mike Hamilton7:15 AM on September 5, 2007 Reply

  • I’ll still continue using the Sansa Connect. Wifi + subscription music is working for me.
    I’m very surprised they added Wifi iTunes store. That’s huge. I wonder if they will be offering DRM-less tracks.

    Rodfather7:17 AM on September 5, 2007 Reply

  • I agree about the price hit, seeing as I paid $499 for a 4GB iPhone just over 30 days ago. I emailed Steve (from my iPhone) asking for an iTunes store credit. We’ll see if I get a reply. :)

    Marc — 7:18 AM on September 5, 2007 Reply

  • Head for the Apple or AT&T store and see if you can get your $200.

    The Apple stores generally will swipe your credit card and give you the difference (unless you bought a 4GB, in which case you’d have to swap) if you bought the item in the past 14 days.

    at&t generally gives you 30 days.

    I’ve had an absolute blast hacking mine so I have no regrets at all. The general fawning and you-are-so-lucky’s have been icing on the cake.

    Scotty — 7:26 AM on September 5, 2007 Reply

  • I hit the live blog at Gizmodo and learned the 4GB is being discontinued but apparently any remaining stock is being sold at the $200 price cut. Rush down to your Apple Store while they last.

    One more thing, despite my father’s mantra of “you snooze, you lose”, apparently patience is good too. I knew a price cut was inevitable, but this is certainly sooner and steeper than I expected. I guess the analysts were due to have one analysis turn true.

    Sumocat8:00 AM on September 5, 2007 Reply

  • You thought the iPhone was worth $600 when you bought, and demonstrated by you actually buying…. get over it… The more of them that are out the there, the stronger the platform becomes.

    George — 8:28 AM on September 5, 2007 Reply

  • The good news is that you can shop iTunes from your second home (aka Starbucks), I thought it was just the last 10 songs too but then they said you can do all of your iTunes from there.

    That’s cool when I’m waiting around for someone, it’s easy to just say meet me at the starbucks at the corner of so and so street..

    bobm — 8:34 AM on September 5, 2007 Reply

  • Imagine if the “walk in our store and buy the song you hear on iTunes” catches on with other retailers. That would be final nail in broadcast radio’s coffin.

    The [Apple/Blogs] combo is already becoming the taste-maker [radio /magazines] used to be.

    Now coffee shops are getting in on that action. Next: Bowling Alleys, Gas Stations, and Funky Clothing Outlets.

    Neurotic Nomad — 11:45 AM on September 5, 2007 Reply

  • I think dropping $200 on the phone was a mistake. They sold 1 million of them. It’s in the timing. Drop the price in 4 to 6 months I think you are OK. 2 months is buyers remorse.
    My opinion.

    acjif98 — 1:21 PM on September 5, 2007 Reply

  • On a side note. I think Steve Jobs has infatuated us with the “next big thing” idea. 30 years ago, we used to wait for new car models every September. Those days are gone but he has tapped into our anticipation of new products based on what’s new within the same idea.
    We used to wait for the new Chevy, now we wait for the new iPod.
    I am not a fan boy but he has taught us that anticipation is as important as the product.
    Pretty smart.
    He should be in the marketing Hall Of Fame.

    acjif98 — 1:33 PM on September 5, 2007 Reply

  • If you’re taking names – count me as someone who could not care less about the price drop. I used the phone everyday, I did not put it in a box hoping I would have a collector’s item. It’s a brilliant freakin’ phone and was glad I was more productive. If $200 is a big deal to you, clearly the iphone is not for you as its clearly of limited value to you and you should only buy items under $200.

    When you take home that new car, it’s worth about $10k less a week later, why not complain about that? Or that after you eat a $200 meal, you’re hungry again in 6 hours?

    Again, if you couldn’t get value out of your iphone in 2 months, clearly, it’s not for you.

    jbelkin — 6:39 PM on September 5, 2007 Reply

  • Pre-emptive gPhone play.

    OpenDude — 4:39 AM on September 6, 2007 Reply

  • Pre-emptive gPhone play.

    OpenDude — 4:40 AM on September 6, 2007 Reply

  • Cutting-edge technology always sells for inflated prices at first and then quickly deflates as supply meets demand. Apple knew what would happen, and they took advantage of it and made $200. You decided to spend $599 on a new, very cutting-edge iPhone, right when it came out. At the time, you thought it was worth it.

    Why on earth should you get any money back now?

    When you buy a computer, in a year it’s worth half as much. Should you get a rebate for half of its price? No, absolutely not. Apple just played the overprice-the-new-device game, and you played right along with them.

    Don’t feel “used as a consumer”, either A) feel proud that you were one of the first iPhoners or B) learn from this and in the future, don’t purchase cutting-edge technology the day it comes out.

    pflanag8:23 PM on September 6, 2007 Reply

  • Well, just read the credit info for iphone purchasers and it is disheartening considering one has to have the phone activated, provide the ATT phone number and serial number. The phones I purchased were gifts and I’m SOL. I say, thanks a lot Mr. Jobs…for nothing. Pretty unfair to anyone who purchased the iphone to give as a gift. Even a charge receipt won’t do one bit of good. Those who get their credit…more power to you!

    discontent iphone purchaser — 7:20 PM on September 14, 2007 Reply

Linkbacks (0)

Subscribe to comments feed

Leave a Reply

Follow us:

Sign up for our daily email:

Podcast

  • Contact Us

    • Send an email to: Kevin C. Tofel
    • Send an email to: James Kendrick
StatCounter